Why people act out of line with their beliefs
canada goose outlet uk If at first you don’t canada goose coats succeed, lower your standards. And if Canada Goose sale you find yourself acting uk canada goose out of line with your beliefs, change them. This sounds like motivational advice from one of the more canadian goose jacket cynical self help books, or perhaps a Groucho Marx line ( are my principles, and if you don’t like them. well, I have others but in fact it is a caricature of one of the most famous theories in social psychology. canada goose outlet uk
canada goose outlet online store Leon Festinger’s Dissonance Theory is an account of how our beliefs rub up against each other, an attempt at a sort of ecology of mind. Dissonance Theory offers an explanation of topics as diverse as why oil company executives might not believe in climate change, why army units have brutal initiation ceremonies, and why famous books might actually be boring. canada goose outlet online store
canada goose outlet uk sale The classic study on dissonance theory was published by Festinger and James Carlsmith in 1959. You can find a copy thanks to the Classics in the History of Psychology archive. I really recommend reading the full thing. Not only is it short, but it is full of enjoyable asides. Back in the day psychology research was a lot more fun to write up. canada goose outlet uk sale
canada goose outlet niagara falls Festinger and Carlsmith were interested in testing what happened when people acted out of line with their beliefs. To do this, they made their participants spend an hour doing two excruciatingly boring tasks. The first task was filling a tray with spools, emptying it, then filling it again (and so on). The second was turning 48 small pegs a quarter turn clockwise; and then once that was finished, going back to the beginning and doing another quarter turn for each peg (and so on). Only after this tedium, and at the point which the participants believed the experiment was over, did the real study get going. The experimenter said that they needed someone to fill in at the last minute and explain the tasks to the next subject. Would they mind? And also, Canada Goose Outlet could they make the points that “It was very enjoyable had cheap Canada Goose a lot of fun enjoyed myself was very interesting was intriguing and was exciting”? canada goose outlet niagara falls
canada goose outlet store calgary Of course the was none of these things. But, being good people, with some pleading if necessary, they all agreed to explain the experiment to the next participant and make these points. The next participant was, of course, a confederate of the experimenter. We’re not told much about her, except that she was an undergraduate specifically hired for the role. The fact that all 71 participants in the experiment were male, and, Canada Goose Outlet that one of the 71 had to be excluded from the final analysis because he demanded her phone number so he could explain things buy canada goose jacket further, suggests that Festinger and Carlsmith weren’t above ensuring that there were some extra motivational factors in the mix. canada goose outlet store calgary
canada goose outlet official Money trap canada goose outlet official
canada goose jacket outlet store For their trouble, the participants were paid $1, $20, or nothing. After explaining the task the original participants answered some questions about how they really felt about the experiment. At the time, many psychologists would have predicted that the group canada goose uk shop paid the most would be affected the canada goose clearance most if our feelings are shaped by rewards, the people paid $20 should be the ones who said they enjoyed it the most. canada goose jacket outlet store
canada goose outlet nyc In fact, people paid $20 tended canada goose factory sale to feel the same about the experiment as the people paid nothing. But something strange happened with the people canada goose coats on sale paid $1. These participants were more likely to say they really did find the experiment enjoyable. They judged the experiment as more important scientifically, and had the highest desire to participate in future similar experiments. Which is weird, since nobody should really want to spend another hour doing mundane, repetitive tasks. canada goose outlet nyc
canada goose jacket outlet uk Festinger’s Dissonance theory explains the result. The is between the actions of the participants and their beliefs about themselves. Here they are, nice guys, lying to an innocent woman. Festinger’s interpretation is that these things may play a role in how the participants act, but they can’t be explicitly relied upon as reasons for acting. So there is a tension between their belief that they are a nice person and the knowledge of how they acted. This is where the cash payment comes in. People paid $20 have an easy rationalisation to hand. “Sure, I lied”, they can say to themselves, “but I did it for $20”. The men who got paid the uk canada goose outlet smaller amount, $1, can’t do this. Giving the money as a reason would make them look cheap, Canada Goose Online as well as mean. Instead, the story goes, they adjust their beliefs to be in line with how they acted. “Sure, the experiment was kind of interesting, just like I told that girl”, “It was fun, I wouldn’t mind being in her position” and so canada goose clearance sale on. canada goose jacket outlet uk
canada goose uk So this is cognitive dissonance at work. Normally it should be a totally healthy process after all, who could object to people being motivated to reduce contradictions in their beliefs (philosophers even make a profession of out this), but in circumstances where some of our actions or our beliefs exist Canada Goose Coats On Sale for reasons which are too complex, too shameful, or canada goose too nebulous to articulate, it can lead to us changing perfectly valid beliefs, such as Canada Goose online how boring and pointless a task was. canada goose uk
canada goose outlet toronto location Fans of cognitive dissonance will tell you Canada Goose Parka that this is why people forced to defend a particular position say because it is their job are likely to end up believing it. It can also suggest a reason for why military services, high school sports teams and college societies have bizarre and punishing initiation rituals. If you’ve been through the ritual, dissonance www.canadagooseuk.net theory predicts, you’re much more likely to believe the canada goose uk outlet group is a valuable one to be a part of (the initiation hurt, and you’re not a fool, so it must have been worth it right?). canada goose outlet toronto location
canada goose outlet store uk For me, I think dissonance theory explains why canada goose black friday sale some really long books have such good reputations, despite the fact that they may be as repetitive and pointless as Festinger’s peg task. Get to the end of canada goose uk black friday a three volume, several thousand page, conceptual novel and you’re faced with a choice: either you wasted your time and money, cheap canada goose uk and you feel a bit of a fool; or the novel is brilliant and you are an insightful consumer of literature. Dissonance theory pushes you towards the latter interpretation, and so buy canada goose jacket cheap swells the crowd of people praising a novel that would be panned if it was 150 pages long. canada goose outlet store uk
canada goose factory outlet vancouver Changing your beliefs to be in line with how you acted may not be the most principled approach. But it is certainly easier than changing how you acted. canada goose factory outlet vancouver
canada goose outlet locations in toronto If you would like to comment on this article or anything else you have seen on Future, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking canada goose outlet locations in toronto.
